Suppliers Need to Argue their Case in the Face of the Smart Export Guarantee

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

On 10 June 2019, the Government lay legislation introducing a new supplier-led, subsidy-free Smart Export Guarantee (SEG). The SEG is designed to replace the Feed-in Tariffs scheme which was discontinued in March 2019. This transition to a Smart Export Guarantee is part of the Conservative vision that ‘electricity generation should be competitive, and market based.’[1]  However, whilst a replacement for the Feed-in Tariff scheme is needed, there are gaps in the scheme that could potentially leave suppliers at a disadvantage. Suppliers may want to act now to urge the Government to rethink elements of the SEG and make sure the tools are in place for a smooth transition.

The SEG could create a postcode lottery for suppliers

The lack of minimum price[2] means that suppliers’ costs are entirely dependent on external factors. This could put suppliers at a competitive disadvantage based on the region they’re in. Areas with high demand, fewer small-scale generators and high consumer energy use, will result in suppliers paying more for energy imports. Lobbying the Government for a flat rate fee would help ensure consistency throughout the country.

The SEG introduction may place further pressure on energy infrastructure

Unlike Feed-in Tariffs, the Smart Export Guarantee is dependent on the generator having a functioning smart meter. Suppliers will therefore face further pressure to speed up the roll out. As there is no guarantee that the supplier purchasing the energy is the same as the supplier responsible for providing the smart meter, suppliers wishing to purchase energy could be dependent on another supplier installing the smart meter. This raises the possibility of energy going to waste while generators wait for installation to be completed. To ensure a smooth transition, suppliers may want to consider lobbying for the SEG to begin after the smart meter rollout has been completed when the necessary infrastructure is in place.

Government has an incentive to listen

By removing the income guarantee of the Feed-in Tariffs, there is little incentive for people to adopt new, early stage, sustainable technologies as the Government wants. Early stage technology is unlikely to be competitive meaning the generator will receive less (if any) income. This could affect renewable deployment, undermining policymakers’ ambitions. Suppliers could succeed with a lobbying effort built on a message of ensuring a diverse future energy mix, as the risks to the Government’s plans from not listening may provide enough leverage to ensure a full hearing.

[1] Chris Skidmore MP, Hansard, 10 June 2019, Vol.661 WS, Link.

[2] Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, The future for small-scale low carbon generation: Smart Export Guarantee – government response, 11 June 2019, Link.



Energy White Paper Audit

Last week Brevia Energy released the findings of its audit of the Government’s 2020 Energy White Paper. The results, which were covered by Energy Live News, highlighted how nearly half of the commitments included in the Energy White Paper have been hit or look likely to be reached. However, the research also showed that answers to the ‘Who Pays?’ question remain needed. With the Government expected to publish both its Net Zero Strategy and Heat and Buildings strategy soon, greater detail on that may be soon forthcoming. That is likely to provoke debate about the direction of policy and open new fronts for businesses to make their case about how the net zero transition should be delivered.

Read More »

At-risk suppliers have put the energy supply industry at risk

Since the beginning of August 2021, the UK has experienced a record increase in gas prices, which has grown into a retail energy crisis that has already caused ten suppliers to exit the market this year. This crisis is the product of several factors, which the UK Government will seek to remedy in the short term and avoid in the long term. This means regulatory reforms are almost inevitable. Once the crisis is over and government turns to reforming the UK’s retail energy market, businesses that operate within it must actively engage with policymakers and regulators to ensure their voices are heard.

Read More »

COP26 Update: New Energy Minister

With less than 50 days until the COP26 Summit, Brevia will be tracking the latest milestones in the UK’s preparations for the upcoming climate conference. This week the Prime Minister carried out an extensive reshuffle of his ministerial team, including a shake up at BEIS, with Greg Hands MP becoming the new Energy Minister. Other notable highlights this week include the publication of the funding details for the upcoming Contracts for Difference (CfD) Round 4 auction.

Read More »
  • Get in touch to arrange your free monitoring trial.