Transport devolution powering forward?

Boris Johnson has set out his intention to give more control over rail services to local politicians.[1] This move increases the need for transport companies and investors to change the way they think about shaping policy and decision-making. Any transfer of power away from Westminster will alter centres of influence, stakeholder targets and the messages required to engage new collections of policy-makers.

Narrowing political space

In a speech in Rotherham, the Prime Minister vowed to ‘give the railways of the North back to the people of the North.’[2] In practice this would mean northern mayors and combined authorities determining local train fares, timetables and budgets.

The pledge partly addresses continued demands from northern leaders, such as the Mayor of Greater Manchester, Andy Burnham, and the Mayor of the Liverpool City Region, Steve Rotheram, for greater powers. It also brings the Government’s position closer to that of the Opposition’s in this area. The Shadow Chancellor, John McDonnell, has recently announced Labour’s plans for a devolved unit in the north of England, which would be responsible for improving infrastructure and the transport system.[3]

Political dynamics might not necessarily equate to realisation

The political motivations are clear: The Conservatives are targeting northern seats ahead of a prospective general election, and northern voters endure some of the least satisfying rail services in the country.[4] However, the announcement has been met with caution from northern leaders who have emphasised the need for funding in conjunction with new powers.[5] Analysis of HM Treasury and Infrastructure and Projects Authority (IPA) data shows that public spending on transport, both in absolute terms, and on a per capita basis is considerably lower in the North than in the South.[6]


Source: House of Commons Library analysis of HM Treasury and IPA data.[7]

For now, this cautious interest should be shared by commercial organisations. The Prime Minister’s announcement should not be taken as a guarantee of a shift in transport administration. As the data demonstrates, powers without increased funding would limit the prospects of significant change. However, with both of the major party’s policy stances converging, the likelihood of devolved transport has arguably increased. The key for businesses will be to acquire the correct insight on developments in order to prepare accordingly.

Change could be coming down the tracks

Any developments in the North will have wider implications for regions in all parts of the country with the emergence of six Sub-national Transport Bodies (SNTBs). Transport for the North is the most established of the SNTBs and its eventual power and funding framework will naturally serve as an example for the others. The final details are expected to be published after the Williams review. Meanwhile, businesses and financiers should pay close attention to the situation, and invest in understanding the politics at play in order to capitalise on any opportunities that might arise.

Brevia Consulting provides straightforward political advice and support to businesses and organisations.

Discover how Brevia can help you and your organisation by contacting the Brevia Transport Team on 020 7091 1650 or contact@brevia.co.uk

[1] Prime Minister’s Office, 10 Downing Street, and The Rt Hon Boris Johnson MP, 13 September 2019, link

[2] Prime Minister’s Office, 10 Downing Street, and The Rt Hon Boris Johnson MP, 13 September 2019, link

[3] Manchester Evening News, 7 July 2019, link

[4] Transport Focus, National Passenger Survey – Spring 2019, p.11,  link

[5] Transport for the North, Response: Prime Minister’s speech at Convention of the North, 13 September 2019,link

[6] House of Commons Library, Transport Spending by Region, 12 February 2018, p.9, link

[7] House of Commons Library, Transport Spending by Region, 12 February 2018, p.5, link

LATEST NEWS

Energy

What the Energy Security Strategy tells us about the Government’s current priorities

After several weeks of reported delays, disagreements and leaks, the Government has finally published its Energy Security Strategy. Crucially, the Strategy provides us with an insight into the main influences and influencers of this Government. With the next general election a mere two years away, the Prime Minister appears to be moving away from the climate focus seen at COP26. Instead focusing on internal party politics and maintaining support within the Conservative . Below, Brevia has unpacked some of the telling signs of what is currently influencing Government direction on energy policy.

Read More »
Brevia

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine will impact UK energy policy

The Russian invasion of Ukraine has changed the world. The ways it has done so are yet to be fully understood. Many of our post Cold War assumptions have been upended: Germany has abandoned its longstanding policy of maintaining a limited armed forces to commit €100 billion to defence spending; Switzerland has departed from its historical neutrality to apply sanctions to Russia; Finland is now openly discussing NATO membership and things we had assumed would never happen continue to do so on a daily basis. Set against the human tragedy that is unfolding in Ukraine, these events can seem small or insignificant in comparison. Nonetheless, they are likely to have enduring consequences for everyone in Europe. Particularly when it comes to how Europe, including the UK, powers itself.

Read More »
General

What did the White Paper tell us about the Levelling Up Agenda?

Last week, the Government published its long-awaited Levelling Up White Paper. The White Paper goes some way to answering the vexed question of ‘What is levelling up?’, by setting out twelve missions the Government hopes to accomplish by 2030. In addition, the Paper sets out a framework for extending devolution in England which could increase the transparency of the process. However, new funding commitments are thin on the ground, and critics suggest the Government has not provided enough money for Levelling Up to succeed.

Read More »
  • Get in touch to arrange your free monitoring trial.